In the sea of deliciously cooked cookies, two names reign supreme: Insomnia Cookies Vs Crumbl. If you’re simply searching for tasty treats, we’d say that both are the perfect choice. Yet, should you be a hard cookie connoisseur, you may expect particular qualities from a bakery and lean toward this one rather than another.
With that many tempting textures and a variety of flavors pleasing our taste buds, it’s no easy task to decide who is the winner of this battle.
Insomnia Cookies Vs Crumbl: A Quick Overview
| Insomnia Cookies | Crumbl | |
| Specialties | Cookie Wiches & Cookie Sundaes | Cookie Cakes & Chilled Sugar Cookies |
| Size | deluxe and regular sizes | generally 4 inches |
| Flavor | classic favorites and creative combinations (rotating menu) | blend of M&M’s and chocolate chunks |
| Store Atmosphere | inviting and casual | appealing and bakery-like |
| Delivery Service | late-night shipping | limited delivery hours |
Insomnia Cookies Vs Crumbl: A Head-To-Head Comparison
While preparing to hunt for the best National Chocolate Chip Cookie Day deals on August 4, why don’t we relax and take some time to do a little comparison of the two eminent players in the cookie industry – Insomnia Cookies Vs Crumbl Cookies?
Size
Every Crumbl Cookie tips the scales at over 150 grams, making them a real heavyweight in the cookie world.
For instance, the beloved Crumbl Milk Chocolate Chip cookie boasts a substantial 152 grams, dwarfing Insomnia Classic Chocolate Chunk cookie, which weighs in at a mere 55 grams – a staggering weight difference of almost three times!
Now, let’s talk about Insomnia Cookies. They’ve got a dynamic duo of cookie categories: the classic lineup featuring the 55-gram Chocolate Chunk and the 42-gram Snickerdoodle cookies, and the Deluxe collection – home to bigger cookies packed with extra goodness. Take the Deluxe Confetti cookie, for example, clocking in at 121 grams.
While not quite matching the size of a Crumbl cookie, these Deluxe treats are giving the heavyweight contenders a run for their money in both size and weight.
Ingredients
Although both companies disclose the ingredients used in their cookies, the exact formulas remain a mystery.
In our testing, we found that both Insomnia and Crumbl featured milk chocolate in their chocolate chip cookies.
While both companies offer various chocolate chip-style cookies, it’s worth noting that Crumbl’s Milk Chocolate Chip cookie stands as their sole standard cookie available every week.
Nutrition
Surprisingly, the Insomnia Chocolate Chunk cookie contains 250 calories and 20 grams of sugar, which is more than the Snickerdoodle’s 180 calories and 13 grams of sugar – an unexpected twist, considering the Snickerdoodle is rolled in cinnamon sugar.
But fear not! Compared to the sugar content in a Starbucks Blonde Vanilla Latte, these cookie delights are still a relatively guilt-free indulgence. So go ahead and savor the cookies, guilt-free, and enjoy every delightful bite.
On the other hand, Crumbl is upfront about their nutritional information, displaying it on the boards at their stores. You can find the calorie content listed next to each cookie.
However, it’s essential to keep in mind that these calorie values are based on serving sizes, not individual cookies.
Taste
Insomnia Cookies truly knows how to tantalize your taste buds with their incredible cookie creations.
First up, we have the delightful Strawberry Shortcake cookie. This sweet treat features a unique combination of strawberry dough blended with white chocolate chips, strawberry bits, and strawberry-infused dried cranberries.
And if you’re in the mood for a burst of color and candy-coated joy, Insomnia’s Classic with M&M’S® cookie is an absolute winner. This playful twist on their classic cookie is packed with the iconic M&M’S®, bringing a delightful crunch and burst of sweetness to every bite.
How about Crumbl? A cookie that’s bursting with delightful surprises.
Our favorite on its menu is the Apple Crumb Cake. Imagine a perfectly snackable apple cookie, generously coated in a luscious brown sugar glaze.
But it doesn’t end there – Crumbl takes it a step further with cubes of baked apples and a crumbly cinnamon streusel on top.
Cost
At first glance, Crumbl cookies may seem more expensive, and on the surface, that’s true. In our area, a single Crumbl cookie will set you back $4.68 – not exactly a budget-friendly treat.
However, there’s more to the story.
Crumbl offers some cost-saving options for cookie enthusiasts. If you opt for a four-pack, the price drops to $15.25, or a six-pack can be yours for $23.48.
While they may not be considered cheap baked goods, these bundles offer some relief for cookie connoisseurs looking to satisfy their cravings without breaking the bank.
On the other hand, a classic Insomnia cookie comes at a more wallet-friendly $2.70, making it appear like a more affordable choice.
However, things get interesting when we consider the Deluxe cookies from Insomnia, which cost $4.50 – almost on par with a Crumbl cookie in terms of price.
Similar to Crumbl, Insomnia also offers packs that make the cookies more budget-friendly.
The Final Verdict
Insomnia Cookies Vs Crumbl: Which factory gains ground? While both cookies serve those craving highly sugary treats, each has its own distinctive flavors.
Some eaters are nuts about the larger size and unique flavors of Crumbl, whereas others are drawn to the chewiness and classic texture of Insomnia.
Regarding dessert, it all boils down to each person’s preference and diet. Thus, we’d say the winner is the one who suits your taste buds and gives you the desired cookie crunchiness.
Next time when you feel like you’re having a sweet tooth, go for these two!
